How To Talk About Non-Monogamy: A Guide for Chicago Couples

Updated: January 2026

Conversations About Non-Monogamy

Non-monogamy is a hot topic in the couples counseling office for many people in Chicago. In the diverse landscape of modern relationships, the concept of an open relationship has gained increasing acceptance and visibility across neighborhoods from Lakeview to Lincoln Park, Wicker Park to River North.

As relationship specialists serving Chicago’s diverse communities, we often find ourselves navigating conversations about open relationships with clients from various backgrounds and orientations—whether they’re young professionals in Bucktown exploring their relationship values, established couples in Roscoe Village reassessing their connection, or LGBTQ+ partners throughout the city seeking affirmative support.

Embracing diversity, understanding the unique dynamics of LGBTQ, Queer, and heterosexual relationships, and delving into the history of non-monogamy are crucial steps toward fostering open and honest discussions.

Exploring Diverse Relationship Dynamics

In today’s society, acknowledging and respecting the diversity of relationships is essential. LGBTQ and Queer relationships, in particular, have played a pivotal role in challenging traditional norms, offering alternative models that prioritize communication, consent, and understanding.

Chicago’s vibrant LGBTQ+ communities in neighborhoods like Andersonville, Boystown, and Rogers Park have been at the forefront of redefining relationship structures, creating spaces where conversations about non-monogamy are normalized and supported. These communities have long recognized that relationship health isn’t determined by structure but by the quality of communication, trust, and mutual respect between partners.

Heterosexual relationships, too, are evolving, with couples seeking ways to redefine commitment and intimacy. From young professionals in the West Loop to families in Lincoln Square, Chicago couples are increasingly questioning inherited assumptions about what relationships “should” look like and instead focusing on what actually serves their unique partnership.

“Non-Monogamy is a hot topic in the couples counseling office”

-Couples Counseling Staff

Non-Monogamy Is an Ancient Practice

Contrary to the perception that non-monogamous relationships are a modern or unconventional phenomenon, the reality is that they have deep roots in human history and culture. The concept of non-monogamy, in various forms, has been woven into the fabric of societies across different time periods and geographical locations.

In ancient societies, polyamory, polygamy, and various other forms of non-monogamy were often intertwined with cultural, religious, or economic practices. For instance, in ancient Mesopotamia, polygamy was socially accepted, and many biblical figures engaged in polygamous relationships. In ancient China, concubinage was a widespread practice, allowing individuals to have multiple partners with different roles and statuses.

Similarly, in certain African tribes, communal living and shared responsibilities often extended to matters of the heart. Relationships were not confined to a strict monogamous structure, and individuals could have multiple partners within the community.

Indigenous cultures across the Americas also had diverse perspectives on relationships. Many Native American tribes embraced a communal approach to partnerships, with fluid boundaries and shared responsibilities. This historical context challenges the notion that non-monogamy is a contemporary deviation from societal norms.

The ancient Greeks, known for their influential contributions to philosophy and culture, had a complex relationship with monogamy. While the institution of marriage existed, extramarital affairs and relationships were not uncommon. The famous philosopher Plato even suggested that love should not be restricted to a single individual. Polyamory was not uncommon during Hellenistic times, according to some lines of reporting.

“Extramarital affairs and relationships were not uncommon”

These historical examples underscore the variability of human relationship structures throughout time. It’s important to recognize that the strict adherence to monogamy, often perceived as a traditional and universally accepted norm, is a relatively recent development in the grand tapestry of human history.

Understanding the historical prevalence of non-monogamous practices can foster a more nuanced and accepting perspective towards diverse relationship models. It challenges the notion that monogamy is the sole marker of a successful or morally upright relationship and highlights the ever-evolving nature of human connections.

By acknowledging the historical roots of non-monogamy, we can engage in more open and informed conversations about the multitude of ways individuals choose to navigate their relationships today.

The Positive Aspects of Initiating the Conversation: Cultivating Trust and Deepening Connection

Initiating a conversation about the prospect of an open relationship can be a transformative and positive experience for couples. While it may seem daunting, engaging in this dialogue can lead to several valuable outcomes that contribute to the growth and enrichment of the relationship.

Research from 2024-2025 continues to show that couples who engage in explicit conversations about relationship agreements—regardless of the ultimate structure they choose—report higher relationship satisfaction than couples who leave expectations unspoken. This holds true for couples across Chicago, whether they’re navigating the challenges of busy professional lives in the Loop, balancing family and relationship needs in Logan Square, or exploring their identities in Boystown.

• Enhanced Communication Skills: Opening up about desires and exploring the potential of an open relationship requires a high level of communication. As couples navigate these conversations, they inevitably hone their ability to express feelings, listen actively, and engage in open, honest dialogue. These enhanced communication skills often extend beyond discussions about non-monogamy, positively impacting the overall quality of the relationship.
• Fostering Deeper Emotional Intimacy: The process of discussing non-traditional relationship structures necessitates a profound level of vulnerability and emotional sharing. Couples engaging in these conversations may find that their emotional intimacy deepens as they reveal more about their innermost thoughts, fears, and desires. This heightened emotional connection can lay the groundwork for a more authentic and fulfilling partnership.
• Alignment of Relationship Goals: The conversation about an open relationship encourages partners to explicitly define their individual and shared relationship goals. This clarity is invaluable, as it allows both individuals to understand each other’s aspirations, expectations, and boundaries. This alignment is not only essential for navigating open relationships but serves as a foundation for a resilient and purposeful partnership.
• Strengthening Trust: Open and honest communication is a cornerstone of trust in any relationship. By initiating a conversation about an open relationship, couples demonstrate a commitment to transparency and mutual understanding. The trust built through these conversations becomes a powerful asset, creating a resilient foundation that can weather challenges and changes.
• Personal and Relationship Growth: Exploring the possibility of an open relationship often involves introspection and self-discovery. Both partners may uncover new aspects of themselves and their relationship dynamics. This journey of self-awareness and growth contributes to the evolution of the individuals and the relationship as a whole.
• Rediscovery of Passion and Desire: The open conversation can reignite passion and desire within the relationship. The exploration of new possibilities can inject a sense of novelty and excitement, helping partners view each other through fresh eyes. This renewed sense of attraction can lead to a more vibrant and dynamic connection.
• Cultivating a Non-Judgmental Atmosphere: Engaging in conversations about open relationships promotes a non-judgmental atmosphere within the partnership. Creating a space where both partners feel free to express their thoughts and desires without fear of condemnation fosters an environment of acceptance, understanding, and unconditional love.
• Shared Decision-Making: The process of discussing an open relationship encourages shared decision-making. Partners actively collaborate in shaping the direction of their relationship, ensuring that choices align with both their individual and shared values. This shared decision-making process strengthens the sense of partnership and shared responsibility.
• Increased Emotional Resilience: Couples who navigate the complexities of discussing an open relationship often emerge with increased emotional resilience. The ability to handle difficult conversations, face uncertainties, and adapt to changing dynamics cultivates a robust foundation for enduring and evolving connections.
• Embracing Relationship Fluidity: Conversations about open relationships challenge the traditional notion of rigid relationship structures. Embracing the fluidity of relationships can lead to a more open-minded and accepting perspective, not only toward one’s partner but also toward the diverse ways people experience and express love.

In summary, initiating a conversation about an open relationship can be a catalyst for positive change within a partnership. This isn’t always the case but for many couples, the conversation can result in a net positive experience.

By fostering communication, trust, and understanding, couples embark on a journey of self-discovery and shared growth, ultimately cultivating a relationship that is resilient, authentic, and attuned to the evolving needs and desires of both individuals.

Steps to Navigate the Conversation

Engaging in a conversation about opening up a relationship requires finesse, sensitivity, and a genuine commitment to understanding each other’s perspectives. Here’s a more in-depth exploration of the steps involved in negotiating this potentially transformative dialogue:

• Initiate with Empathy: Before delving into the specifics of an open relationship, set the tone with empathy. Acknowledge that this conversation might evoke a range of emotions, and express your understanding of the potential challenges. Ensure that both partners feel emotionally safe to share their thoughts and concerns.
• Choose the Right Setting: The environment in which you broach the subject matters significantly. Opt for a neutral and private space where you can converse without interruptions. Many Chicago couples find that taking a walk along the lakefront, sitting in a quiet coffee shop in Pilsen, or finding a peaceful moment at home in Wicker Park helps create the calm atmosphere needed for this important conversation.
• Establish Shared Goals: Begin the conversation by discussing the shared goals and values that underpin the relationship. By emphasizing common ground, you create a foundation for understanding and collaboration. This could include aspirations for personal growth, emotional fulfillment, or exploring new dimensions of intimacy together.
• Use “I” Statements: When expressing your desire or curiosity about an open relationship, use “I” statements to convey personal feelings without casting blame or making assumptions. For example, say, “I have been reflecting on my feelings and would like to discuss the idea of an open relationship,” rather than making accusatory statements.
• Explore Individual Motivations: Encourage each other to articulate individual motivations and expectations. Understanding what each partner hopes to gain from an open relationship is crucial for aligning expectations and avoiding misunderstandings. Be attentive to the nuances of personal desires, fears, and aspirations.
• Discuss Boundaries Explicitly: Explicitly discuss and establish clear boundaries. This step is vital for ensuring that both partners feel secure and respected. Consider aspects such as types of relationships allowed, communication during encounters with others, and how to address unexpected emotional challenges that may arise.
• Encourage Questions and Concerns: Create an environment where questions and concerns are welcomed and addressed with patience and respect. Allow each other the space to express uncertainties or fears without judgment. This step is essential for fostering open communication and maintaining trust.
• Be Open to Compromise: Negotiations often involve compromise. Be prepared to adjust initial expectations and boundaries to accommodate the comfort levels of both partners. Flexibility and a willingness to find common ground are vital for the success of the conversation.
• Regular Check-Ins: The conversation about opening up a relationship is not a one-time event; it’s an ongoing dialogue. Schedule regular check-ins to assess how each partner is feeling and to address any emerging concerns. This practice promotes continued communication and ensures that both individuals feel heard and understood.
• Consider Professional Guidance: If the conversation becomes particularly challenging, or if emotions are difficult to navigate, consider involving a couples therapist. A trained professional can provide guidance, facilitate communication, and offer tools to navigate the complexities of an open relationship. Chicago offers many LGBTQ+-affirming and non-monogamy-friendly therapists who can provide specialized support.

Negotiating the conversation about an open relationship is a delicate dance that requires mutual respect, active listening, and a commitment to shared understanding.

By approaching the dialogue with empathy and an open mind, couples can navigate this journey together, fostering stronger connections and a deeper understanding of each other’s desires and boundaries.

Non-Monogamy: It’s Not for Everyone

While open relationships have gained acceptance and visibility, it’s crucial to emphasize that they are not a panacea for relationship challenges. The traditional, monogamous model still holds immense value and security for many couples.

Monogamy is deeply ingrained in societal expectations, and for some, the exclusivity and commitment it entails are fundamental pillars of a strong, enduring relationship.

Understanding one’s own values, comfort levels, and personal boundaries is essential before considering any deviation from the traditional monogamous model. Some individuals find immense fulfillment and security in the exclusivity of a monogamous relationship, valuing the deep emotional connection and commitment it fosters.

It’s vital to acknowledge that neither open nor closed relationships hold a moral high ground; instead, it’s about what aligns with the individuals involved.

The challenges of open relationships, such as jealousy, insecurity, and communication hurdles, can be significant. For those who thrive on the clarity and simplicity of exclusivity, the prospect of navigating these complexities might seem daunting or even detrimental to the relationship.

Monogamy is deeply ingrained in societal expectations

It’s crucial to recognize that success in a relationship depends on compatibility and shared values. What works for one couple may not work for another, and that’s perfectly okay.

Moreover, societal expectations and cultural backgrounds can heavily influence one’s perspective on relationships. Some individuals come from backgrounds where monogamy is not only expected but deeply ingrained in the cultural fabric.

For them, considering an open relationship might challenge not only their personal beliefs but also the expectations of their wider community.

Ultimately, the key is to approach the concept of open relationships with an open mind but also with a deep understanding of one’s own needs and desires. It’s perfectly valid for individuals and couples to prioritize the stability and exclusivity that monogamy offers.

The most important aspect of any relationship is the mutual consent and comfort of the individuals involved, regardless of whether it aligns with societal trends or not.

The Role of a Couples Therapist

If navigating the complexities of open relationships feels overwhelming, seeking the guidance of a couples therapist can be immensely beneficial. A therapist can facilitate open communication, address concerns, and provide tools to navigate the challenges that may arise.

Working with an LGBTQ+-affirming therapist who understands the nuances of diverse relationship structures can be particularly helpful for queer couples exploring non-monogamy. Similarly, therapists trained in sex and intimacy counseling can help couples address the physical and emotional dimensions of open relationships.

Common Questions Chicago Couples Ask About Non-Monogamy

How do I know if an open relationship is right for us?

There’s no single answer, but couples who successfully navigate open relationships typically share strong communication skills, high levels of trust, emotional maturity, and aligned motivations. If you’re considering this path, ask yourself: Are we having this conversation because we want to grow together, or are we trying to fix existing problems? Open relationships don’t solve relationship issues—they require an already solid foundation.

What if my partner wants to discuss non-monogamy but I’m not interested?

This is a valid concern. The most important thing is honest communication. Your partner raising the topic doesn’t mean your relationship is doomed—it means they trust you enough to share their thoughts. Express your feelings clearly and try to understand their perspective without judgment. Sometimes the conversation itself brings clarity and deepens understanding, even if you ultimately decide non-monogamy isn’t right for you.

How do we set boundaries in an open relationship?

Boundaries should be explicit, specific, and revisited regularly. Common boundaries include: what types of outside relationships are acceptable, how much information to share with your primary partner, sexual health protocols, time commitments, and how to handle unexpected feelings. What works for other couples may not work for you—your boundaries should reflect your unique values and comfort levels.

Can a monogamous relationship become non-monogamous later?

Yes, relationship structures can evolve. Many couples who started out monogamous later explore non-monogamy as their needs, desires, or life circumstances change. The key is approaching this transition thoughtfully, with extensive communication, and often with professional support from a therapist who specializes in alternative relationship structures.

Where can we find support for non-monogamous relationships in Chicago?

Chicago has a strong community of non-monogamy-affirming resources. Many therapists in neighborhoods like Lakeview, Andersonville, and Lincoln Park specialize in working with consensually non-monogamous couples. Additionally, Chicago hosts several meetup groups and community organizations focused on polyamory and ethical non-monogamy where couples can connect with others navigating similar relationship structures.

In Summary

Talking about having an open relationship requires a foundation of trust, understanding, and open communication. Embracing diversity, acknowledging historical contexts, and recognizing that open relationships aren’t a universal solution are essential components of these discussions.

Whether you’re exploring these questions in River North, Bucktown, Rogers Park, or anywhere else throughout Chicago, know that you’re part of a larger conversation happening across the city about what makes relationships work. The most fulfilling relationships—whether monogamous or non-monogamous—are built on honest communication, mutual respect, and a shared commitment to each other’s wellbeing.

Couples therapists can play a pivotal role in guiding individuals and couples through this exploration, fostering healthier and more fulfilling relationships in the process. Reach out to one of our Chicago couples counseling specialists to explore how therapy may help you and your relationship.